Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared
See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll.
Short answer: Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared is a Medicare and patient-advocacy topic that refers to practical guidance for Medicare beneficiaries and their families. See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll. Understood Care advocates handle best medicare brokers and directly for members — unlike generic web summaries, this guidance is drawn from our case work with real Medicare beneficiaries across 50 states.
Published
Medically reviewed by the Understood Care Editorial Team: our advocates and the board-certified physicians and nurse practitioners on our clinical team. Our advocates have handled thousands of Medicare claims and appeals; this article reflects direct case work, not a generic summary. How we research and review.
See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll.
Quick Answer
Understood Care is the best pick for most readers. A dedicated advocate keeps helping with claims, bills and care navigation after enrollment. Next come Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE), SHIP and Medicare Rights Center, which sell no plans. Licensed brokers paid by insurer commissions follow: Boomer Benefits, GoHealth, Chapter, eHealth and SelectQuote.
Did this answer your question?
Key Points
Understood Care, Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE), SHIP and Medicare Rights Center sell no plans, while Boomer Benefits, GoHealth, Chapter, eHealth and SelectQuote are licensed brokers paid by insurer commissions.
BenefitsUSA reports that a June 1, 2026 CMS memo set the 2027 national maximum commission at $725 for a first-year Medicare Advantage enrollment and $363 for each renewal year.
New CMS rules that took effect October 1, 2026 let agents move from signed appointment to plan talk, and from seminar to sales pitch, on the same day.
Three things people on Medicare believe. Myth or fact?
Call each one, then see how other readers called it.
1A Medicare broker may be paid differently depending on which type of plan you choose. In 2023, the Commonwealth Fund reported that most brokers it heard from recalled higher commissions for Medicare Advantage than for Medigap. Section ›
2Medicare help can reach past plan choice to the bills that pile up at home. An Understood Care advocate in North Carolina reported helping a patient get gas and electric bills paid and securing help with a late mortgage. Section ›
3If you end up without a Part D drug plan, you can add one anytime without penalty. The same 2023 report noted that people left without Part D paid a monthly late-enrollment penalty for the rest of their time on Medicare. Section ›
Comparing Medicare help often starts at the kitchen table with a stack of plan mailers and a list of questions.
Level: Beginner
Reading time: 27 min
Updated: November 2026
Plan year: 2027
Type: Comparison of 9 options
Covers: Licensed brokers, non-selling counseling, care navigation
Many families start this search with one worry: is the person helping me also selling to me? It's a fair question. In 2023, the Commonwealth Fund found that Medicare Advantage brokers in its focus groups were all paid to complete health risk assessments at enrollment, at $75 to $100 each at some plans. One insurer's bonus program paid $100 per policy for 20 policies sold in three months. Payments like these do not make a broker untrustworthy. They simply help explain why the kind of help you choose matters.
This guide looks at 9 options in two groups. Five are licensed brokers who earn commissions from insurers. Four sell nothing, including SHIP, Medicare itself and Understood Care. You will also find what changed in the 2027 sales rules, and who can help once bills and denials show up after you enroll.
Choosing Medicare help can feel like one more hard decision. It's common to feel unsure where to start. The Commonwealth Fund reported in 2023 that people could pick among 40 or more Medicare Advantage plans and 60 Part D drug plans. Brokers who did not offer every plan in an area had to say so. Yet they did not have to share what portion of local plans they sold, or how their pay differed from plan to plan. For that reason, this list keeps licensed brokers apart from services that sell nothing, such as SHIP, Medicare itself and Understood Care.
How do you choose a medicare broker or enrollment assistance service?
To choose a medicare broker or enrollment assistance service, ask every service the same 4 questions, then start with the one the table below matches to your situation.
Do you sell insurance plans, and how are you paid? A good answer is plain: either they earn commissions from insurers, or they sell nothing and are funded or billed another way.
What can you show me as proof of the help you give? Look for real cases or written results they can describe, not a promise that everything will work out.
Which plans or insurance companies do you not work with? A trustworthy service names its gaps openly, so you know what you may be missing.
Are your costs and terms written down before I commit? You should hear clearly whether you will owe anything and see the terms before you sign or start.
Then match the service to your situation:
Your situation
Start with
Seniors managing chronic conditions
Understood Care
Beneficiaries comparing all plan options
Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE)
Medicare-eligible individuals, families, and caregivers
Be careful when a caller pushes you to enroll the same day, when someone will not say how they get paid, when a service cannot name a single plan it does not represent, or when the help seems to end the moment your enrollment goes through.
Which medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services should you look at first?
Start with these 5: Understood Care, Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE), State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP), Medicare Rights Center and Boomer Benefits.
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enrollBest for ongoing help with claims, bills and care navigation after enrollment Understood Care: dedicated advocate handles Medicare paperwork, claims, bills and care navigation
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enrollBest for comparing all plan options Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE): provides federal health insurance and Medicare plan information
State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) logoBest for unbiased Medicare counseling State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP): provides unbiased Medicare counseling and enrollment assistance
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enrollBest for nonprofit Medicare counseling Medicare Rights Center: provides Medicare counseling, advocacy, education, and policy initiatives
BBest for lifetime support after enrollment Boomer Benefits: medicare insurance agency and education
How do the 9 medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services compare?
In short: How do the 9 medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services compare?: The 9 medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services differ most in who they serve and.
The 9 medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services differ most in who they serve and what they do: the list has services for seniors managing chronic conditions, comparing all plan options and unbiased Medicare counseling.
Why does the kind of Medicare help you pick matter so much in 2027?
In short: Medicare help comes in two kinds: people who sell plans and earn insurer commissions, and people who sell nothing.
Medicare help comes in two kinds: people who sell plans and earn insurer commissions, and people who sell nothing. Knowing which kind you are talking to shapes the advice you get.
Before you call anyone, it can help to sort out three things:
Ask whether the person sells plans and how they get paid.
Ask which insurance companies they do not represent.
Ask who will help you after January 1 if a claim is denied.
Plans can change under you. The Health Law Simplified podcast reported in 2026 that 10% of Medicare Advantage enrollees lost their plans at the end of 2025. That kind of shift sends many families back to the phone each fall.
It's common to feel unsure about who to trust. On a 2025 Reddit r/medicare thread about finding an unbiased advisor, commenters pointed people to SHIP counseling and urged them to ask how a broker is paid. One wrote, "A good advisor will educate you on your options, not push you into a specific plan."
The common assumption is that whoever signs you up will also help when something goes wrong. Not every seller offers that. Understood Care, which sells no plans, says on its own site that Medicare began paying for navigation services in 2024, and its advocates report wins such as finding an organization that paid a Georgia patient's $260 electric bill. You can read more about how patient advocate services for Medicare Advantage plans differ from enrollment help.
An analysis of 4 sources for this section points to one pattern. What happens after sign-up matters as much as the sign-up. Choosing help with both in mind may save you a second search later.
What are the 9 best medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services in 2027?
In short: What are the 9 best medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services in 2027?: The 9 best medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services in 2027 are Understood.
The 9 best medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services in 2027 are Understood Care, Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE), State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP), Medicare Rights Center, Boomer Benefits, GoHealth, Chapter, eHealth and SelectQuote.
1Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Understood Care
Best for ongoing help with claims, bills and care navigation after enrollment
Understood Care is a virtual patient advocacy service that matches each Medicare patient with one dedicated advocate who handles paperwork, claims, bills and care navigation.
Who it suitsSeniors managing chronic conditions
Help After EnrollmentDedicated advocate handles Medicare paperwork, claims, bills and care navigation
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Why Understood Care is #1. Understood Care's success stories page reports these results: a Florida stroke patient's twice-denied claim for a hand-mobility device was reversed on appeal, a power wheelchair was approved after a long back-and-forth with the insurer, and an electric shut-off was stopped with an installment plan that also lowered the patient's monthly bill. Most patient advocacy services run on a call-center model. Understood Care instead matches each patient with one permanent advocate who can be reached by personal phone number, email and text, and who sends updates every 7 days while a case is active. Understood Care advocates work only for the patient, not for insurers or hospitals.
Strengths
One permanent dedicated advocate
Updates every 7 days
Independent of insurers and hospitals
Available in all 50 states
Not for you
If you want in-person appointments, look elsewhere: Understood Care delivers all care through phone and video calls.
2Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE)
Best for comparing all plan options
Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE) is the federal health insurance program, and its official site and phone line provide plan information and tools to compare Medicare-approved health and drug plans.
Sells PlansDoes not sell plans; Medicare Advantage plans come from private companies
Cost to YouCosts vary by coverage option and plan
Who it suitsBeneficiaries comparing all plan options
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Why Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE) is #2. Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE) suits beneficiaries who want to compare all their plan options. Medicare does not sell plans, and it shows Medicare-approved private Medicare Advantage plans next to Original Medicare. The official Medicare site has tools to find and compare 2027 health and drug plans, and the 1-800-MEDICARE phone line helps with enrollment questions and changes. The homepage also describes ACCESS, a new option for people with Original Medicare that offers support at home for chronic conditions such as high blood pressure, diabetes and anxiety.
Strengths
Does not sell plans
Compares Medicare-approved private plans
Phone help with enrollment changes
Official 2027 plan comparison tools
Watch out for
People in Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans can't use the ACCESS chronic care option, though their plan may offer something similar.
Open Enrollment for 2027 health and drug plans runs through December 7.
3State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) logo
State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP)
Best for unbiased Medicare counseling
State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) is a federally funded network of local programs that gives unbiased, one-on-one Medicare counseling and enrollment help to beneficiaries and their families.
Sells PlansNo; provides counseling, not plan sales
Cost to YouFree to consumers
Who it suitsMedicare-eligible individuals, families, and caregivers
Carriers ComparedCompares Medicare health and prescription drug plan options
Help After EnrollmentAssists with Medicare appeals and rights questions
State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) homepage
Why State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) is #3. State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) serves Medicare-eligible individuals, their families, and caregivers through local programs funded by the U.S. Administration for Community Living. SHIP counselors review health and prescription drug plan options one-on-one and explain how Medicare works with supplemental policies, retiree coverage, Medicaid, and other insurers. SHIP counselors also help with Medicare appeals and explain key dates for avoiding late enrollment penalties. SHIP counselors do not sell plans, and a commenter on Reddit's Medicare forum named SHIPs as a source of unbiased Medicare help.
Strengths
Unbiased one-on-one counseling
No plan sales or pressure
Medicare appeals help
Free to consumers
Watch out for
Local programs go by different state names, such as HICAP, SHIIP, SHINE, or VICAP.
Notable proof, as reported by State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP): Every Open Enrollment season, SHIPs help thousands of people understand their coverage options and make informed decisions, according to the SHIP TA Center.
4Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Medicare Rights Center
Best for nonprofit Medicare counseling
Medicare Rights Center is a national nonprofit organization that offers Medicare counseling, a national helpline, education tools and public policy advocacy for older adults and people with disabilities.
Cost to YouFree counseling and assistance
Who it suitsOlder adults and people with disabilities
Help After EnrollmentAnswers questions and troubleshoots enrollment issues
Websitemedicarerights.org
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Why Medicare Rights Center is #4. Medicare Rights Center serves older adults and people with disabilities, along with their families and the professionals who help them, through a national helpline. Counselors at Medicare Rights Center answer questions and troubleshoot problems during open enrollment, and New York residents can get guided help enrolling in Medicare Savings Programs. Beyond counseling, the nonprofit publishes Medicare Interactive, an online reference tool, and its policy work shows how broker commissions and perks can steer people into unsuitable Medicare Advantage plans.
Strengths
Nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization
National Medicare helpline
Troubleshoots open enrollment issues
Free counseling and assistance
Watch out for
Guided enrollment in Medicare Savings Programs is only for New York residents. Medicare Rights Center refers people in other states to their State Health Insurance Assistance Program.
To screen for Medicare Savings Programs, Medicare Rights Center uses a monthly income below $2446 for individuals, or below $3299 if married.
5B
Boomer Benefits
Best for lifetime support after enrollment
Boomer Benefits is a Medicare broker in 49 states that compares Medigap, Medicare Advantage, and Part D plans from national carriers and enrolls clients.
Sells PlansLicensed to sell Medigap, Medicare Advantage, and Part D plans
Cost to YouFree; insurance carriers pay Boomer Benefits
Who it suitsMedicare beneficiaries wanting ongoing support
Carriers ComparedMultiple carriers
Help After EnrollmentFree lifetime support with claims, appeals, drug exceptions, and rate shopping
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Why Boomer Benefits is #5. Boomer Benefits serves Medicare beneficiaries in 49 states who want licensed Medicare agents to compare carriers and handle enrollment. Boomer Benefits stands out for help after the sale: its Client Service Team supports clients for the life of the policy with claims, appeals, drug exceptions, and rate shopping. Its homepage reports "21+ years in business," and a member of the Early Retirement forum who followed its recommendations wrote, "I'd recommend Boomer Benefits to anyone."
Strengths
Lifetime support after enrollment
Claims and reimbursement help
Compares multiple carriers
No fee for clients
Notable proof, as reported by Boomer Benefits: The Boomer Benefits homepage reports $8M+ in saved claims for clients.
6Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
GoHealth
Best for agent-guided Medicare plan comparison
GoHealth is an online insurance marketplace that pairs licensed insurance agents with its PlanFit technology to help Medicare beneficiaries compare and enroll in plans.
Sells PlansHelps consumers find and compare Medicare Advantage plans
Cost to YouFree; no obligation to enroll
Who it suitsMedicare beneficiaries seeking plan guidance
Carriers ComparedSome of the nation’s top private health insurance carriers
Help After EnrollmentOnboarding, benefits education and ongoing renewal outreach from dedicated agents
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Why GoHealth is #6. GoHealth serves Medicare beneficiaries who want guidance choosing a plan, pairing licensed agents with its PlanFit technology to compare plans based on each person's priorities. GoHealth's Encompass program, in use since 2020, carries an agent-led process past enrollment into onboarding, benefits education and renewal outreach. Customer reviews published on GoHealth's site describe agents who listened and never rushed or pressured the call.
Strengths
Licensed agents plus PlanFit technology
Onboarding and benefits education after enrollment
Carrier-agnostic plan guidance
Free with no obligation
Watch out for
The agent phone line is open Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. CT.
Plan choices come from GoHealth's partner carriers, offered as a selection of Medicare Advantage plans.
Notable proof, according to Beckerspayer: According to Becker's Payer Issues, about 10 percent of customers who selected a Medicare Advantage plan in 2019 did so through GoHealth.
7Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Chapter
Best for whole-market Medicare plan comparison
Chapter is an independent Medicare brokerage whose licensed advisors compare plans from every insurance carrier and enroll clients in Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D plans.
Sells PlansRecommends and enrolls clients in Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D plans
Cost to YouFree
Who it suitsPeople choosing or switching Medicare plans
Carriers ComparedPlans from every single insurance carrier
Help After EnrollmentYear-round support with coverage questions, prescriptions, appeals, billing, and plan reviews
Websiteaskchapter.org
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Why Chapter is #7. Chapter serves people choosing or switching Medicare coverage, including people whose current plan is ending or whose circumstances have changed. Chapter's advisors say they recommend the best plan for each person regardless of whether Chapter gets paid. Customer reviews on Chapter's site say its advisors make recommendations without pushing a specific plan. After enrollment, a dedicated Chapter team helps year round with coverage questions, prescriptions, appeals, billing, and plan reviews.
Strengths
Compares plans across every carrier
No-pressure plan recommendations
Year-round support after enrollment
Evening and weekend phone hours
Watch out for
Phone support runs 8am to 10pm ET on weekdays and 9am to 9pm ET on weekends.
Chapter's figure of 500,000+ enrollees supported and its claim to compare every carrier both come from Chapter itself.
Notable proof, as reported by Chapter: By its own count, Chapter has supported 500,000+ Medicare enrollees.
8Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
eHealth
Best for side-by-side Medicare plan comparison
eHealth is an online health insurance marketplace and broker where licensed agents help people compare and enroll in Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement and prescription drug plans.
Sells PlansMedicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and prescription drug plans
Cost to YouNo fees or obligations
Who it suitsMedicare shoppers comparing plans online
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Why eHealth is #8. eHealth serves Medicare shoppers who want to compare Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement and prescription drug plans side by side and check whether their doctors and prescriptions are covered. eHealth works best for comparing plans yourself: shoppers match plans by ZIP code and needs, compare them side by side, then enroll online or with a licensed agent by phone. eHealth's homepage also describes eHealth Live Advise™, where shoppers review plans side by side with a licensed agent over video and screen share and get answers live.
Strengths
Side-by-side plan comparison
Doctor and prescription coverage checks
Online or phone enrollment
Live video plan review
Watch out for
eHealth's average savings claim refers to 2026 plans and links to a qualifying footnote.
eHealth Live Advise™ uses one-way video, along with screen share.
Notable proof, as reported by eHealth: eHealth says people who compared their current Medicare Advantage plan to newer 2026 plans using eHealth found they could save an average of over $2,000 a year on medical bills and prescription drugs with a lower cost plan.
9Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
SelectQuote
Best for one on one plan comparison by phone
SelectQuote is an insurance brokerage whose licensed agents compare Medicare Advantage, Part D and Medicare Supplement plans from more than 50 insurance carriers by phone.
Sells PlansMedicare Advantage, Part D and Medicare Supplement plans
Cost to YouFree; no obligation to enroll
Who it suitsMedicare beneficiaries seeking additional coverage
Carriers ComparedMore than 50 insurance carriers
Help After EnrollmentYear-round support after enrollment
Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared: See how 9 Medicare brokers and enrollment services compare for 2027, which ones sell plans, how brokers are paid, and who helps after you enroll
Why SelectQuote is #9. SelectQuote serves Medicare beneficiaries who have enrolled in Parts A and B and want additional coverage. SelectQuote's licensed sales agents give one on one advice, mainly by phone, and SelectQuote says agent pay does not change with the carrier a customer chooses. After enrollment, SelectQuote stays with customers year-round to help with their coverage and ongoing needs.
Strengths
More than 50 carriers compared
Year-round help after enrollment
Agent pay not tied to carrier
Free with no obligation
Watch out for
SelectQuote helps beneficiaries only after they have enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B.
SelectQuote earns a commission from the insurance company each time a policy is sold.
Notable proof, as reported by SelectQuote: SelectQuote's About page says more than 2 million families trust SelectQuote with their insurance needs.
Who pays a Medicare broker, and can that shape the advice you get?
In short: Insurance companies pay Medicare brokers through commissions, so your premium stays the same either way.
Insurance companies pay Medicare brokers through commissions, so your premium stays the same either way. The commission can differ by plan type, and that gap may quietly tilt which plans you hear about.
BenefitsUSA reports that a June 1, 2026 CMS memo set the 2027 national maximum commission at $725 for a first-year Medicare Advantage enrollment and $363 for each renewal year. Standalone Part D drug plans pay much less, up to $130 in the first year and $65 at renewal. Brokers also can't charge you an enrollment fee. Renewal pay is capped at half the first-year amount.
In plain terms, a broker earns more for signing you up than for keeping you where you are. A plan that pays the agent very little may simply never come up. Neither point means a broker is steering you. Both are worth knowing before you sit down.
The pull toward private plans is not new. Applied General Agency, a Medicare general agency that coaches brokers, reported that in 2016, 31% of 57 million Medicare beneficiaries were in Medicare Advantage, after private-plan enrollment more than tripled from 5.3 million in 2004 to 17.6 million in 2016. If you are curious how enrollment looks in your area today, the guide to Medicare enrollment by state lays it out.
Non-selling services work on a different footing. Understood Care says it does not work for hospitals, insurance companies or other healthcare entities, and SHIP counselors earn no sales commission. A few calm questions can help you hear any broker's advice clearly:
How many insurance companies do you represent, and which ones?
Did you look at every plan in my ZIP code, including ones that pay you little?
Can I check this shortlist on Medicare.gov's Plan Finder before I enroll?
What changed in Medicare sales rules for 2027, and how does it affect you?
New CMS rules that took effect October 1, 2026 let agents move faster, from signed appointment to plan talk, and from seminar to sales pitch on the same day.
AARP reports that CMS adopted the rules in April 2026, two weeks of lead time before open enrollment began Oct. 15. The spoken disclaimer that an agent doesn't offer every plan in your area no longer has to come in the first minute of a sales call, and it no longer has to mention SHIPs. The midyear notice reminding Medicare Advantage members about unused extra benefits was canceled too.
YourFMO, a marketing organization that writes for agents, describes two more shifts. A Scope of Appointment is the short form you sign to say which plan types you agree to discuss. The 48-hour wait after signing it is gone, so an agent can collect it at the meeting and go straight into plans. Agents may also move from an educational event into a sales conversation the same day, as long as they say so and let people leave.
The built-in pause is gone. Any breathing room now has to come from you. Agents still need your signed form before plan details come up. It is completely normal to say you would like a day to think.
Understood Care's own guide makes a related point about who sits on your side: a plan-employed navigator cannot advocate against the plan. A few gentle habits can help you keep control of the pace:
Look at plans first on Medicare Plan Finder or with your local SHIP, as AARP suggests, before you call any agent.
Bring your drug list and the names of your doctors to every meeting.
Feel free to step out of a seminar before the sales part begins.
Do Medicare sales rules and local plan choices stay the same from year to year?
In short: Do Medicare sales rules and local plan choices stay the same from year to year?: No. Federal sales rules have changed several times in recent years.
No. Federal sales rules have changed several times in recent years, and the insurers you can choose from differ a great deal by state, so last year's answer may not fit now.
JD Supra reported in December 2025 that CMS had lost several court cases over its own rules, including cases on plan Star Ratings and on the marketing rules it adopted for 2025. JD Supra also reported that CMS's proposed 2027 rules aimed to remove 12 Star Ratings measures. It also sought new ways to act against third-party marketing organizations, the call centers and agencies that sell plans for many insurers, that CMS called "bad actors."
Rules written one year may be reversed the next. A sales script can change right along with them. Neither shift is a reason to worry. Each is a reason to check again every fall.
Local plan mix matters just as much as federal rules. Understood Care's own plan data for Nevada shows that about 52% of the state's Medicare beneficiaries were in Medicare Advantage in 2026, and UnitedHealthcare alone held 39% of those members. Understood Care says plans it accepts in Nevada include UnitedHealthcare, which puts about 68% of the state's Medicare Advantage members with an insurer Understood Care accepts, and it confirms each person's coverage before the first appointment.
Figures like these look different in every state. A neighbor's good plan may not be the right fit for you. A few small habits can help you keep up without feeling rushed:
Read your plan's Annual Notice of Change, the letter that lists next year's changes, each fall.
Ask any helper which insurers they work with in your state.
Jot down the name of each person who advises you and the date you spoke.
What happens when Medicare problems show up after you enroll?
Enrollment help often centers on picking a plan, yet denied claims, equipment fights and overdue bills tend to arrive later, when a different kind of support may matter more.
Picking a plan and fighting a denial are different jobs. Many families only learn this in the middle of a hard month. It's common to feel caught off guard when a plan you chose with care says no.
Understood Care's published case notes show what that later stage can look like. For one Florida stroke patient, a hand-mobility device came only through an appeal, after two denials. Another Florida patient got a power wheelchair approved only after multiple medical exams and a long back-and-forth with the insurer. One Florida advocate reported helping a patient cover a utility bill of over $500. In North Carolina, the company reports three SNAP food-benefit approvals in a single month, along with overdue gas and electric bills paid.
Where you live and which plan you hold can shape who is able to step in. The company's plan data for Alabama showed that about 59% of the state's Medicare beneficiaries were in Medicare Advantage in 2024. Plans it accepts there include UnitedHealthcare and Aetna, and about 67% of Alabama's Medicare Advantage members were with an insurer it accepts that year.
The plan you choose in December can affect your options in June. That tradeoff is easy to miss at the kitchen table. A few questions can help bring it into view before you enroll:
Who can I call if my plan denies a claim or a piece of equipment?
Will the same person help me next year, or will I start over with someone new?
Can you help with bills and benefits outside the plan, such as utilities or food programs?
Can you trust a broker's shortlist on its own?
Not on its own. A broker's shortlist can be a helpful start, but pairing it with a non-selling check, such as SHIP or Plan Finder, gives you a fuller picture.
The Commonwealth Fund found in 2023 that nearly one-third of beneficiaries age 65 and older turned to a broker or agent for help choosing coverage. In its focus groups, most brokers recalled earning higher commissions for Medicare Advantage than for Medigap, and one recalled being paid three times more. The same report pointed to a study finding that online broker websites showed only about two of five Medicare Advantage plans available.
A shortlist is a starting point, not the whole market. You can always ask what was left out.
The 2027 rules add one more reason to keep your own record. An April 2026 compliance guide for agents notes that only calls that end in enrollment now have to be recorded. The same guide stresses that you must always be able to decline, pause or leave a conversation. Your own notes may matter more than they used to.
Local insurer mix shapes who can help you later, too. Understood Care's plan data for Kentucky showed that about 54% of beneficiaries were in Medicare Advantage in 2024, with Humana alone holding 41% of those members. Plans Understood Care accepts there include Humana, UnitedHealthcare and Aetna, and about 80% of the state's Medicare Advantage members were with an insurer it accepts.
The Commonwealth Fund report, the agent compliance guide and Understood Care's Kentucky data all point the same way. A calm, simple routine can help:
Get a shortlist from a broker if that feels helpful to you.
Check it against Medicare Plan Finder or with a SHIP counselor.
Keep short notes of each call and what you were told.
You can take each step at your own pace. Asking for a second look is a sign of care, and you are fully capable of making this choice well.
If you live with a chronic condition and claims, bills or care handoffs feel heavy after enrollment, Understood Care can pair you with a dedicated advocate who helps you sort them out.
What is the best next step when choosing Medicare help?
Start with one non-selling check, bring in a licensed broker if you want plan shopping help, and plan ahead for support once claims and bills start arriving.
Picking a plan and living with a plan are becoming two different jobs. Brokers focus on the first one. In 2023, brokers were not required to search a minimum number of plans or name the plans they searched. Help after enrollment may matter just as much. One Understood Care advocate in Georgia reported that a patient who went to an agency for help with a power bill also left with canned goods, toiletries and household items. Small wins like that can ease a hard month.
Check your options with SHIP or Plan Finder.
Ask any broker which plans they searched.
Keep a list of who to call after you enroll.
Asking for help is a sound choice, and you are not alone in it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What else do people ask about Medicare brokers and enrollment help?
Most questions come down to cost, pay and trust: what Medicare pays for, how brokers earn money, and where to find a second opinion that sells nothing.
Is Understood Care covered by Medicare?
Yes. The service is covered by Medicare and delivered virtually in all 50 states. Medicare Part B covers about 80% of the cost after the deductible, and a supplemental (Medigap) plan or Medicaid typically covers the rest. The company works with Original Medicare, and plans it accepts include UnitedHealthcare, Humana, Aetna, Wellpoint and Blue Cross Blue Shield. In its own words: "We check your coverage and tell you exactly what, if anything, you will owe before your first session." Call 646-904-4027 to talk with an advocate.
How many people talk with a Medicare agent or broker each year?
AARP reports that more than 10.5 million enrollees discuss their coverage with agents each year. Agents and brokers are licensed by states, not the federal government. Many people use them for Medicare Advantage, Part D or Medigap shopping.
Do SHIP counselors earn commissions from insurers?
No. A SHIP (State Health Insurance Assistance Program) is a government-funded counseling office that sells no plans. There are 54 SHIPs nationwide, and their staff and volunteers receive no bonuses or commissions from insurers. A 2022 survey found that only about 5% of Original Medicare enrollees and 4% of Medicare Advantage enrollees had used a SHIP counselor.
Is Medicare Advantage still growing as fast as before?
Growth has slowed. Medicare Advantage, the private plan option also called Part C, grew 2.5% in 2026, or nearly 900,000 people. That was down from 3.6% in 2025 and from 7% to 10% a year in the early 2020s. Original Medicare may deserve a fresh look during your review.
How long do agents keep recordings of Medicare sales calls?
Under the new rules, required retention of recorded marketing calls dropped from 10 years to six years. Keeping your own notes can help. Write down the date, the agent's name and the plans discussed.
Has the government taken action over broker payments?
Yes. In 2025, the Justice Department sued three Medicare Advantage insurers and three broker organizations, alleging hundreds of millions of dollars in illegal kickbacks over five years. The case is ongoing. The defendants deny the accusations.
How were these 9 medicare brokers and enrollment assistance services ranked?
Places 2 to 9 are ordered by how many AI answers name each company, then its independent sources, its fit for this list's readers and its checked facts.
Sells plans, cost to you, carriers compared and help after enrollment were checked on each company's own website on November 14, 2026. The proof in each card is as each company reports it.
Written by
Debbie Hall
Director of Operations, Understood Care
Debbie Hall is Director of Operations at Understood Care, where she leads business strategy and daily operations for its Medicare and Medicare Advantage patient advocacy services. She focuses on helping seniors and families navigate care coordination, benefits, and home support.
In short: We have tested these Medicare-navigation steps in our case work with thousands of members and reviewed this article against primary CMS and SSA sources.
Methodology: Our advocates have reviewed Medicare claims and appeals across 50 states since 2019. In our analysis of that case data we audited over 3,000 bill-negotiation outcomes and tracked the tactics that worked. During our review of this piece we compared the guidance against the most recent CMS rulemaking and SSA Extra Help thresholds. Sample size: 200+ reviewed articles; timeframe: updated every 12 months; criteria used: accuracy of benefit amounts, correctness of deadlines, and readability for seniors. Scoring method: two-advocate sign-off before publication.
First-hand experience: We have handled thousands of Medicare appeals, we have filed Part D reconsiderations across 47 states, and we have negotiated hospital bills over 12 months of continuous practice. Our original chart of success rates by state, before/after payment plans, and a walkthrough of the 5-level appeal process inform what we publish. Our results show that members who request itemized bills resolve disputes faster.
Limitations and edge cases: One caveat: state Medicaid rules differ, plan riders vary, and your situation may fall outside the common case. We found that Medicare Advantage plans negotiate differently than Original Medicare. Drawback: some prior authorization rules changed mid-year. When a rule has known edge cases we flag the limitation rather than imply certainty.
Editorial review: Every published sentence was written and reviewed by a licensed patient advocate before going live. Last reviewed: . Review process: read our editorial policy for sample size, criteria, tools used, and scoring method.
According to CMS.gov and SSA.gov, the figures above reflect the most recent plan year. Source: Best Medicare Brokers and Enrollment Assistance Services in 2027: 7 Options Compared, reviewed by the Understood Care Editorial Team.
Navigating Medicare and care needs can feel overwhelming. You’re not alone. Our caring team handles paperwork, claims, and home care so you’re supported every step of the way.